Six Nations Surpasses Rugby Championship, Declares All Blacks Legend Justin Marshall
Paris, France – March 17, 2026 – In a stunning assessment following a thrilling 2026 edition, former All Blacks star Justin Marshall has stated the Six Nations is now “arguably better” than the Rugby Championship. The declaration comes after France clinched the Six Nations title on Saturday with a dramatic 48-46 victory over England in a match widely considered one of the greatest in the competition’s history. While the southern hemisphere traditionally dominates Rugby World Cups, Marshall believes the increased quality and compelling nature of this year’s Six Nations have tipped the scales. He specifically pointed to the Bledisloe Cup’s one-sided nature as a detriment to the Rugby Championship, noting the Six Nations offers a more competitive and constructed tournament with teams actively playing attacking rugby, evidenced by the high-scoring games throughout the competition.
Six Nations Surpasses Rugby Championship, Declares All Blacks Legend Justin Marshall
Former All Blacks star Justin Marshall has ignited debate within the rugby world, asserting that the Six Nations is “arguably better” than the Rugby Championship following a captivating 2026 edition.
France’s Dramatic Victory Fuels the Discussion
France clinched the Six Nations title on Saturday with a breathtaking 48-46 victory over England, secured by a last-minute penalty from Thomas Ramos.
This match, widely hailed as one of the greatest in the competition’s history, showcased the very best of the sport and has significantly contributed to the shifting perception of the two major rugby tournaments.
Southern Hemisphere Dominance Challenged
While the Southern Hemisphere has historically dominated Rugby World Cups, winning nine of the ten tournaments held, and currently holds the top two positions in the World Rugby rankings, the Six Nations has always been a compelling spectacle.
Its rich history, deeply ingrained traditions, and intense rivalries have long made it an incredible competition.
Though, the Rugby Championship traditionally held an edge in overall quality, a distinction Marshall suggests is fading.
Bledisloe Cup Impact on Rugby Championship
Marshall pinpointed the Bledisloe Cup as a potential detriment to the Rugby Championship’s standing.
Australia’s consistent inability to secure a win against Modern Zealand in the Bledisloe Cup has created an imbalance, potentially diminishing the overall competitiveness of the tournament.
“Probably the Bledisloe’s a bit damaging for the tournament at the moment due to the fact that Australia haven’t been able to win that Bledisloe and the All Blacks have dominated them,” Marshall stated on The Breakdown.
Six Nations: A More Constructed and Engaging Tournament
According to Marshall, the Six Nations’ historical significance and carefully constructed format contribute to its growing appeal.
“But that Six Nations tournament, because of its history, is arguably a better and more constructed tournament, and the teams are playing rugby now,” he explained.
The tournament’s recent high-scoring matches, a departure from the low-scoring affairs of the past, further demonstrate its evolution and increasing excitement.
Did you grasp? The France vs. England match on Saturday was a thrilling display of attacking rugby, with both teams refusing to yield, resulting in a record-breaking scoreline for a Six Nations encounter.
A Shift in Rugby’s Competitive Landscape
Marshall highlighted the improved quality of play across all Six Nations teams, even England, noting a willingness to engage in open, attacking rugby.
“You’re not seeing 9-6 or 9-3 or 12-9, whatever it might be. They are playing, we saw a lot of points in all those games.”
He praised the outstanding game between France and England, comparing it favorably to the legendary 2000 match between Australia and New Zealand.
“It was an outstanding game of rugby, there’s no doubt about it,” Marshall said.
“What I loved about this contest was it wasn’t in a way non-constructed. England had to work hard for their points, but they were prepared to work hard.”
Pro Tip: Keep an eye on emerging players like Louis Bielle-Biarrey of France, who are injecting fresh energy and excitement into the game.
Looking Ahead: The Future of International Rugby
The debate sparked by Marshall’s comments underscores a potential shift in the balance of power within international rugby.
The Six Nations’ ability to consistently deliver high-quality, engaging matches, coupled with the Rugby Championship’s challenges, suggests a future where the European tournament may continue to gain prominence.
FAQ
- What did Justin Marshall say about the Six Nations? He believes the Six Nations is “arguably better” than the Rugby Championship.
- Which teams played in the dramatic Six Nations final? France and England.
- What is the Bledisloe Cup? An annual rugby union series between Australia and New Zealand.
- Why is the Bledisloe Cup considered damaging to the Rugby Championship? Because of the consistent dominance of New Zealand over Australia.
What are your thoughts on Marshall’s assessment? Share your opinions in the comments below and join the conversation!
Explore more rugby news and analysis on 247sports.new.